Protection Paladin Best in Slot (BiS) Gear List - Wrath Classic (WOTLK)
Class
Spec
Phase
Do you have a list that sims better? Submit it here and we'll update after testing it.
Gear
Slot
Source

Tempered Titansteel Helm


head
Blacksmithing
Trainer (440)

Chained Military Gorget
neck
Vendor
Emblem of Heroism (25)

Pauldrons of the Colossus


shoulder
Gundrak (H)
Drakkari Colossus (25%)

Cloak of Peaceful Resolutions

back
Reputation
The Wyrmrest Accord - Honored

Heroes' Redemption Breastplate



chest
Multiple
Archavon the Stone Watcher (10), Emblem of Heroism (80)
Bracers of the Herald
Bracer - Major Stamina
wrist
Ahn'kahet: Old Kingdom (H)
Herald Volazj (25%)
Heroes' Redemption Handguards
Glove Reinforcements
hands
Multiple
Archavon the Stone Watcher (10), Emblem of Heroism (60)
Waistguard of Living Iron
waist
Vendor
Emblem of Heroism (40)
Bolstered Legplates
Frosthide Leg Armor
legs
Violet Hold (H)
Cyanigosa (25%)
Sabatons of Draconic Vigor
Boots - Greater Fortitude
feet
Reputation
The Wyrmrest Accord - Revered
Titanium Earthguard Ring
finger 1
Jewelcrafting
BoP Pattern (430)
Keystone Great-Ring
finger 2
Drak'Tharon Keep (H)
The Prophet Tharon'ja (25%)
Essence of Gossamer
trinket 1
Azjol-Nerub (H)
Hadronox (25%)
Seal of the Pantheon
trinket 2
Halls of Lightning
Loken (13%)
Red Sword of Courage
Weapon - Accuracy
weapon
Utgarde Pinnacle (H)
King Ymiron (25%)
Royal Crest of Lordaeron
Titanium Plating
off hand
Culling of Stratholme (H)
Mal'Ganis (20%)
Libram of Obstruction
relic
Vendor
Emblem of Heroism (15)